Which Tools Work Best for Understanding Process Problems?

Struggling with process problems? Discover the tools to find clarity and drive improvement

When setting out to improve a process, diving into the “Learn about the Process” phase of the Improvement Cycle is crucial. This stage is where we build our understanding of how the process currently operates, identify where things may be going wrong, and gather insights that will shape our improvement strategies. To do this effectively, we need to use the right tools to gather data, define expectations, and establish the metrics that matter.

In this Improvement Focus Collection, we’ll walk you through five key tools for learning about a process: the Value Proposition Statement, the Kano Model, Operational Definitions, Measures of Process Performance, and Selecting Key Measures.

1. Value Proposition Statement: Review the Process Purpose

The Value Proposition Statement serves as a guiding light throughout an improvement journey. It’s a concise description that captures the purpose of the process, the needs of its customers, and the intended benefits. By articulating this up front, we align our problem investigation efforts with what truly matters.

When you’re facing a process problem, starting with the Value Proposition Statement helps illuminate why the process exists in the first place. This tool keeps the focus on the bigger picture—what the process is truly meant to deliver. If there’s a gap between this purpose and what’s actually happening, it’s a clear signal that something needs to change.

Redesign the Value Proposition Statement

Which Tools Work Best for Understanding Process Problems?

2. Kano Model: Understand What the Customer Really Wants

The Kano Model is a valuable tool for understanding process problems by categorising customer needs into three types: expected, wanted, and delight factors. Using this model helps identify which elements of the process are essential and which areas might differentiate your service or product.

When you map customer expectations to the process’s actual performance using the Kano Model, you can see that not all customer needs carry equal importance. Some seemingly minor issues may lead to significant dissatisfaction if they’re tied to basic expectations. This approach helps you focus your efforts on what will truly impact customer satisfaction.

Using the Kano Model to Listen to Your Customer

Watch Now

Understanding The Voice of The Customer

Listen Now

Improving Through the Voice of the Customer: On-Demand Webinar

Watch Now

3. Operational Definitions: Bring Clarity to the Process

Once you understand customer expectations, the next step in addressing process problems is to define the key elements of the process using operational definitions.

An operational definition provides a clear and precise description of what is being measured or observed, ensuring consistency among all stakeholders. For instance, if you’re investigating “on-time delivery,” it’s crucial to define what “on-time” means. Does it refer to when the product leaves the warehouse, the time it arrives at the customer’s doorstep, or something else? Without this clarity, you risk misinterpreting data and making misguided decisions.

Deming’s insight that “Without an operational definition, investigation of a problem will be costly and ineffective, almost certain to lead to endless bickering and controversy” is particularly relevant here.

Establish Shared Definitions

4. Measures of Process Performance: Assess How the Process Behaves

To effectively understand process problems, you need to assess how well the process is performing by examining specific measures that reflect its efficiency, effectiveness, and quality. These measures differ from outcomes (like customer satisfaction) because they focus on the inner workings of the process itself.

Common measures of process performance include cycle time, error rates, and throughput. These indicators provide insights into where bottlenecks or inconsistencies are occurring within the process. By measuring the right aspects, you can uncover patterns or behaviours in the data that directly point to underlying issues.

Understand Throughput Yield

5. Select Key Measures: Focus on What Really Matters

With operational definitions and process measures in place, it’s crucial to prioritise which measures will guide your improvement work. This isn’t about measuring everything; it’s about identifying a few key metrics that will help you understand whether the process changes lead to the desired improvements.

Selecting key measures ensures you stay focused on what’s most impactful, rather than getting distracted by metrics that may not drive meaningful change. The measures should align with the Value Proposition Statement and customer expectations identified through the Kano Model.

Identify Key Metrics

Which Tools Work Best for Understanding Process Problems?- image - 8

Connecting It All: A Structured Approach to Learning About the Process

To bring everything together, here’s how these tools fit into a structured approach for investigating and understanding a process:

Begin with a Value Proposition Statement to set the context and define what success looks like.
Use the Kano Model to understand different levels of customer needs and how they influence the process.
Establish Operational Definitions for key terms and metrics to ensure everyone is measuring and interpreting data consistently.
Identify Measures of Process Performance to assess how the process operates in its current state.
Select Key Measures that will guide the improvement efforts and monitor progress.

By following this sequence, we gain a holistic understanding of the process, from customer expectations to process behaviours, setting the stage for targeted and effective improvements.

Laying a Strong Foundation for Process Improvement

The “Learn about the Process” phase of the Improvement Cycle is crucial for building a solid foundation for successful improvement work. By employing tools like the Value Proposition Statement, Kano Model, and Operational Definitions, you can clearly define the problem, prioritise customer needs, and measure what truly matters. This understanding empowers you to tackle process challenges with confidence.

As you prepare for the next steps, remember that the journey doesn’t end here. Armed with this knowledge, you are ready to embrace data visualisation tools like Run Charts, Histograms, and Control Charts to monitor and analyse your processes effectively. Watch this space for our next Improvement Focus Collection, where we’ll dive deep into these visualisation techniques, equipping you with the skills to drive impactful change through your process improvement journey.

MEETS US AT THE GEMBA!

GEMBAfication is PMI’s new podcast for improvement professionals looking for an honest view of what improvement really looks like in practice. Because in our world, every experience is valuable.

Listen Now